I’ve always had a fondness for canned cream of mushroom soup that bordered on a perversion. Even though I only occasionally purchased it, just having it in the house was such a temptation that I often ended up eating it undiluted, thick and yummy.
Of course I haven’t been eating much cream of mushroom soup since I went gluten-free, which is more than two years ago, and certainly no canned Campbell’s as in my diet’s previous incarnation. People have been posting about wanting cream of mushroom soups to eat and concentrate to put in casseroles, such as that famed green bean casserole with the Funyons instead of the crunchy fried onion bits (I can’t comment on that, as I haven’t tried it). I also read that Progresso makes a gluten-free cream of mushroom soup, but I haven’t looked for it. It must have something to do with that icon of Americana, the red and white soup can.
Then last week I had an idea. I had been making sausage gravy with water instead of the milk I can no longer consume. Though you can get the right texture and a brown gravy-like appearance, the flavor is nonexistent. This time I blended some blanched almonds with water - about 2 ounces of almonds to 1 cup of water - until smooth, added it to the pan drippings, and slowly cooked until it had simmered for a while. It was much better than not bad. The almond particles made the texture, if anything, a bit floury, which when you’ve gone without flour for this long, is not unattractive. Almonds don’t have those starch particles that explode and cook smooth like wheat flour does. Also, it was very rich, much more than I would have predicted from the calories in the almonds that went into it.
I found that leftovers were as good as fresh, and I added a spoonful of this to several things I ate last week - pasta, frozen spinach, polenta, eggs mollet… The recipe made a sauce that was too thick, so I need to tinker with the exact proportions of almonds to liquid before I decide to make any sauce recommendations.
Now for the big deal: cream of mushroom soup. I figured it might be a little thin to use 1 ounce of almonds per cup of liquid, but I had to start somewhere, so I made the commitment to that proportion. I put the almonds in the blender jar with a tablespoon of sherry and added water to just below the level of the almonds. I whirled, scraping down chunks off the cannister walls and adding liquid a little bit at a time until it was perfectly smooth and about as thick as a pancake batter. I diced 8 ounces of portobello mushrooms and sauteed them in a tablespoon of butter (substitute olive oil if you can’t tolerate butter). Then I just added the thick almond milk to the pot with the mushrooms in it and heated it, stirring, until it had simmered for a few minutes.
Salt and pepper to taste. Yum. To make this into a condensed-style cream of mushroom soup, just use about half the water.
Cream of Mushroom Soup